Gifts for the Giving
Pilgrimage is not only about the journey. As a ritual, it literally enshrines the destination. And if arriving at a holy place to seek wholeness is the pilgrim’s goal, there is an aspect of pilgrimage beyond simply walking there that is often forgotten - the giving of gifts.
We can see an echo of this in the nylon ribbons hanging on special trees, or modern coins flung into holy wells. But these good intentions are not well thought-through, and will likely pollute the holy place pilgrims are trying to engage with. This is not recommended.
If a holy place is not a static object, and if holiness is a relationship, this implies a ‘give-and-take’ reciprocity. In the Middle Ages, this aspect of pilgrimage was well-known. Shrines fought to claim their relics were the best, as the flow of pilgrims seeking wholeness meant the flow of gifts. One of the most common gifts pilgrims gave was beeswax candles in the shape of the body-part that needed healing. In an age when candles were the only source of light, this was an important economic contribution.
Furthermore, wealthy pilgrims often competed for the kudos of giving the richest gift (the gift honours the giver). Hence the much celebrated ‘Regale of France’ - the world’s biggest ruby - donated to the shrine of Thomas Becket in Canterbury by the King of France (this became Henry VIII’s thumb ring after Reformation).
When pilgrimage was banned in 1538, one of its often quoted and much disliked ‘crimes’ was the distastefully mercantile approach to gift-collecting, the Pardoner-esque greed for financial largesse, seen among the controllers of shrines. This is why, I believe, the concept of gifts has not been so well highlighted in the modern renewal of pilgrimage traditions. We have inherited a distaste for the material matter in association with holy places. But this is not helpful, for our world and bodies are (amongst their other properties) material realities. As such, to find the relationship you seek with a holy place, it is recommended to come bearing gifts.